Skip to content
The Product Guys
All teardowns
SteamStrategy6 min read

The wishlist is the marketing channel

Save it now, buy it when the discount email lands.

The surface
The store page, the wishlist, the seasonal sale front page, and the notification that a wishlisted game is discounted.
What the user wants
I want games I will actually play, at a price I will not feel stupid about later.
01

Wishlist before purchase

Every store page offers a wishlist action alongside the buy control, and wishlisting requires only an account.

Capturing deferred intent

Most visits to a game page do not end in a purchase, and without a wishlist that interest is simply lost. Capturing it converts a dead visit into a durable, permissioned marketing contact. The buyer gets something too, which is why they agree.

02

The discount notification

When a wishlisted title goes on sale, the customer is notified with the discount stated, and wishlists are visible to developers in aggregate.

Trigger tied to a self-declared want

This is the rare promotional message the recipient asked for, aimed at an item they already chose. Response rates for a self-selected trigger are in a different class to broadcast marketing. For developers, the wishlist count also becomes the main pre-launch demand signal, which shapes how the whole industry plans releases.

03

Seasonal sales as events

Discount periods run on a known calendar with a themed front page, and they end on a stated date.

Manufactured periodicity

Making sales predictable trains customers to wait, which looks like a mistake and is not: it concentrates demand into moments when attention is enormous. The deadline is real and the event becomes something people show up for. Steam swapped continuous small revenue for large, planned spikes.

04

The reference price

Discounts are shown as a percentage with the previous price struck through beside the new one.

anchoring: The first number you see shapes every judgement that follows. against a prior price

A price is only cheap relative to something, and the crossed-out figure supplies the comparison. Because the reference is the game's own established price rather than a competitor's, the claim is verifiable in a way retail discount anchors often are not. Verifiability is what keeps this from being a dark pattern: An interface built to get an outcome the user would reject if it were stated plainly..

05

Reviews as a percentage with a label

Games display an aggregate recommendation percentage translated into phrases such as Mixed or Very Positive, with recent and all-time scores shown separately.

Interpreted social proof: People look at what others did to decide what is correct here.

A raw percentage requires the buyer to know what is normal for the category, and most do not. A word does the interpretation for them. Splitting recent from lifetime is the sharper idea, because it catches games that have decayed or recovered, which a single average would hide.

06

Refunds with a stated rule

Steam publishes a refund policy based on time played and days since purchase, applied through a self-service request.

Reversibility as a purchase enabler

Uncertainty about whether a game will run or be any good is the main reason a buyer hesitates. A clear numerical rule removes that risk without requiring a negotiation. It costs refunds and buys a much larger volume of confident purchases.

The list the customer builds for you

per thousand wishlist addsAdded to a wishlist1000Still wanted when a sale runs610 (-390)Notification opened240 (-370)Store page reopened150 (-90)Bought68 (-82)
A schematic thousand wishlist adds. Nothing here was bought as advertising: the customer assembled the audience, named the product, and granted permission to be told when the price moves. The step to protect is the first one, because the whole channel is sized by it.

What not to copy

  • Predictable deep discounting teaches customers that the list price is fiction, which compresses launch revenue and pushes small developers toward permanent discounting to stay visible.
  • Wishlist counts have become the industry's demand metric, and optimising for wishlists rewards trailer craft and page marketing rather than the finished game.
  • Review scores are gameable and brigadeable, and a cluster of negative reviews about an unrelated business decision lands on the same number a buyer uses to judge the game.
  • Store discovery still favours titles that already sell, so the wishlist mechanism mostly compounds attention that existed rather than distributing it.

The takeaway

A wishlist is a permissioned marketing list the customer builds for you, so make saving as easy as buying.

Finished the teardown? Bank it and the day counts toward your run.

Where the principles come from

  • Thinking, Fast and Slow (anchoring, reference points), Daniel Kahneman
  • Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion (scarcity, commitment), Robert Cialdini
  • Predictably Irrational (the cost of zero and of free choice), Dan Ariely
  • Hooked: How to Build Habit-Forming Products, Nir Eyal

Written from public behaviour of the product, not from inside it. Interfaces change often, so treat the flow described here as of the time of writing and check the live product before quoting it.